Blog Hero Image

reading fluency

Reading Fluency vs Comprehension: Key Differences

by

If your child can read a page of text out loud without stumbling over words, but then cannot tell you a single thing about what they just read — you are not imagining a problem. What you are witnessing is one of the most misunderstood distinctions in reading development: the difference between reading fluency and reading comprehension.

Many parents — and even some teachers — assume that if a child can read the words, they must be understanding them. But reading fluency and reading comprehension are two separate skills, powered by two different sets of cognitive abilities. A child can be strong in one and weak in the other. And without understanding this distinction, children often go without the right support for years.

At The Learnability, we work with children every day who have exactly this profile. In this guide we explain what reading fluency and reading comprehension are, how they differ, why a child can have one without the other, and what parents can do when either skill is weak.

What Is Reading Fluency?

Reading fluency is the ability to read text accurately, quickly, and with appropriate expression. A fluent reader recognises words automatically — without having to stop and sound them out — and reads at a pace that sounds natural and conversational. Fluency is what makes reading feel effortless rather than laboured.

There are three core components of reading fluency:

Accuracy

Accuracy means reading the correct words on the page without substituting, omitting, or misreading them. A child with poor accuracy may read "horse" as "house" or skip words entirely, changing the meaning of what they are reading. Accuracy is the foundation of fluency — without it, neither speed nor expression is possible.

Speed (Reading Rate)

Reading rate refers to how quickly a child can read a passage of text. A child who reads very slowly is using significant cognitive effort to decode each word — effort that should be available for understanding meaning. When decoding is not automatic, reading feels effortful and slow, and comprehension suffers as a result.

Expression (Prosody)

Prosody is the ability to read with appropriate rhythm, tone, and expression — pausing at commas, raising pitch at question marks, and conveying the emotional tone of the text. A child who reads in a flat, robotic monotone — even if they read accurately — is showing signs of limited fluency. Prosody reflects a child's understanding of the text as language, not just as a sequence of sounds.

Reading fluency develops primarily through the automatisation of word recognition — the ability to instantly recognise words as whole units without conscious decoding effort. This is the skill developed by our Seeing Stars program, which builds symbol imagery — the mental visualisation of letters and words that underlies automatic word recognition.

What Is Reading Comprehension?

Reading comprehension is the ability to understand, interpret, and make meaning from written text. It is the ultimate purpose of reading — the reason we read in the first place. A child who comprehends what they read can retell a story, answer questions about a passage, make inferences, identify the main idea, and connect what they read to their own knowledge and experience.

Reading comprehension depends on a wide range of cognitive skills including:

  • Vocabulary knowledge — understanding the meaning of individual words
  • Background knowledge — having enough prior knowledge to make sense of the content
  • Language comprehension — understanding how sentences and paragraphs convey meaning
  • Concept imagery — the ability to create vivid mental images from language
  • Working memory — holding earlier parts of a text in mind while reading later parts
  • Inferencing — reading between the lines and understanding implied meaning
  • Metacognition — monitoring your own understanding as you read

The most critical of these for many children who struggle with comprehension is concept imagery — the ability to create a mental movie from language. This is the core skill developed by our Visualizing and Verbalizing program, which directly addresses weak reading comprehension even when a child reads accurately and fluently.

How Are Reading Fluency and Comprehension Related?

Reading fluency and reading comprehension are closely connected — but they are not the same thing, and one does not automatically produce the other.

The relationship works like this: when a child has to use significant mental effort to decode individual words, there is very little cognitive capacity left over for understanding meaning. Think of the brain as having a limited amount of processing power. If most of that power is consumed by figuring out what the words say, almost none is available for thinking about what the words mean.

This is why improving fluency often leads to improvements in comprehension — not because fluency teaches comprehension, but because it frees up the cognitive resources needed for comprehension to happen. When word recognition becomes automatic, the brain can focus on meaning.

However — and this is the crucial point — fluency does not guarantee comprehension. A child can develop excellent word recognition and read quickly and accurately, while still having a significant weakness in the cognitive skills that comprehension requires. When this happens, improving fluency alone will not fix the comprehension problem. The underlying cognitive weakness needs to be directly addressed.

Can a Child Have Good Fluency But Poor Comprehension?

Yes — and this is far more common than most parents and teachers realise. Children with good fluency but poor comprehension are sometimes called word callers — they can call out the words on the page accurately and at a reasonable speed, but they are not constructing meaning from what they read.

This profile is particularly common in children who have strong phonological processing skills — they have learned to decode efficiently — but weak concept imagery or limited vocabulary and background knowledge. They may have sailed through early reading instruction, which focuses heavily on decoding, only to hit a wall in upper primary school when the reading demands shift from learning to read to reading to learn.

Signs your child may have good fluency but poor comprehension include:

  • Reads aloud accurately and at a normal speed but cannot retell what they read
  • Struggles to answer comprehension questions even on texts they have just read
  • Cannot identify the main idea of a passage
  • Finds it hard to make inferences or read between the lines
  • Does not notice when something they have read does not make sense
  • Performs well on spelling and word reading tests but poorly on comprehension tasks
  • Dislikes reading despite being able to read accurately

If this sounds familiar, our Visualizing and Verbalizing program is specifically designed for this profile. It directly develops the concept imagery skills that comprehension depends on, transforming passive word recognition into active meaning-making. Contact The Learnability to find out if this program is right for your child.

Can a Child Have Poor Fluency But Good Comprehension?

Yes — though this is less common. Some children struggle significantly with decoding and reading fluency but have strong oral language comprehension and concept imagery. When they listen to a text being read aloud, they understand it well. But when they have to read it themselves, the effort of decoding leaves them too exhausted to focus on meaning.

Children with dyslexia often fall into this category. Their phonological processing weakness makes decoding effortful and slow, but their underlying language comprehension and reasoning abilities are strong. With the right structured literacy intervention — such as our Orton-Gillingham tutoring or the Wilson Reading System — these children can develop the decoding automaticity they need, freeing their strong comprehension abilities to shine.

What Causes Poor Reading Fluency?

Poor reading fluency is most commonly caused by weak phonological processing — the ability to connect letters to their corresponding sounds. When a child cannot decode words automatically, reading remains slow and effortful regardless of how much they practise. The most effective interventions for reading fluency target phonological processing directly through structured literacy approaches.

Weak symbol imagery — the ability to visualise letters and words as mental pictures — is another common cause of poor fluency. Children with weak symbol imagery cannot instantly recognise familiar words as whole units. They have to decode the same words over and over again, never developing the automaticity that fluent reading requires. Our Seeing Stars program directly addresses this underlying cause.

What Causes Poor Reading Comprehension?

Poor reading comprehension has multiple possible underlying causes, which is why accurate assessment is so important before choosing an intervention. The most common causes include:

Weak Concept Imagery

The inability to create vivid mental images from language is the most common underlying cause of reading comprehension difficulties in children who read accurately. Without concept imagery, language is processed as disconnected words rather than as meaningful wholes. This is the primary target of our Visualizing and Verbalizing program.

Limited Vocabulary

A child who does not know the meaning of many of the words in a text cannot fully comprehend it, regardless of how fluently they read. Vocabulary development is an important component of reading comprehension support.

Limited Background Knowledge

Understanding a text often requires background knowledge about the topic. Children with limited life experience or limited exposure to a wide range of topics may struggle with comprehension on unfamiliar subjects.

Working Memory Difficulties

Reading comprehension requires holding earlier parts of a text in mind while processing later parts. Children with working memory difficulties may understand individual sentences but lose the thread of a longer passage.

Language Processing Difficulties

Some children have broader difficulties processing and understanding language — whether spoken or written. These children may need support that goes beyond reading intervention to address underlying language processing weaknesses. Our special needs tutoring is designed to support children with this kind of complex profile.

How The Learnability Supports Both Fluency and Comprehension

At The Learnability, we begin every student journey with a thorough assessment to identify exactly where a child's reading difficulties lie — whether in fluency, comprehension, or both. This ensures that every program we recommend is targeting the right underlying skills for that individual child.

For children with fluency difficulties, our Orton-Gillingham tutoring, Wilson Reading System, and Seeing Stars program build the phonological processing and symbol imagery skills that automatic word recognition depends on.

For children with comprehension difficulties, our Visualizing and Verbalizing program develops the concept imagery skills that transform reading from passive word recognition into active meaning-making.

For children who struggle with both, we create a personalised program that addresses both sets of skills in a carefully sequenced way — ensuring the foundations are built before the higher-level skills are developed.

You can explore our full range of reading intervention programs on our website, or contact us directly to speak with a specialist about your child's specific needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

My child reads fast but does not understand — what should I do?

This is a classic sign of weak concept imagery — the ability to create mental pictures from language. The Visualizing and Verbalizing program is specifically designed for this profile. Contact The Learnability for an assessment and we will confirm whether this is the right program for your child.

My child reads slowly and also does not understand — where do we start?

When both fluency and comprehension are weak, we typically address fluency first — building decoding automaticity through structured literacy intervention. As fluency improves and cognitive resources are freed up, comprehension often improves too. If comprehension difficulties persist after fluency has improved, we then introduce targeted comprehension support.

Will reading more books improve my child's comprehension?

Reading widely does support comprehension development — but only if a child already has sufficient fluency and basic comprehension skills to benefit from reading. A child with significant underlying weaknesses in concept imagery or language processing will not improve their comprehension simply by reading more. They need targeted intervention that addresses the underlying cause.

Is poor reading comprehension a sign of dyslexia?

Not necessarily. Dyslexia primarily affects phonological processing and reading fluency. Poor comprehension in the absence of fluency difficulties is more likely to indicate weak concept imagery or a language processing difficulty rather than dyslexia. A proper assessment is the most reliable way to identify what is causing the comprehension difficulty.

How long does it take to improve reading comprehension?

Progress depends on the severity of the underlying difficulty, the intensity of intervention, and how consistently the program is followed. Many children show meaningful improvement within a few months of consistent, targeted intervention. Contact us for a realistic picture of what to expect for your child specifically.

Help Your Child Read and Understand Today

Reading fluency and reading comprehension are both essential — and both teachable. Whether your child struggles to read the words, struggles to understand them, or struggles with both, the right targeted intervention can make a real and lasting difference.

At The Learnability, our specialist tutors deliver personalised, evidence-based reading support online through one-on-one sessions. We identify exactly where your child's difficulties lie and target them precisely — giving your child the reading skills and confidence they need to thrive.

Book your free trial session today and take the first step toward giving your child the reading support they deserve.

You can also contact us directly or call us at (310) 218-9466 — we are always happy to help.

What Is the Seeing Stars Program and How Does It Help Struggling Readers?

by

If your child has been struggling with reading, you may have tried different approaches and still found that progress is slow or inconsistent. Perhaps your child can sound out words one day but forgets them the next. Perhaps they struggle to hold words in their mind long enough to read a full sentence. If this sounds familiar, the Seeing Stars program could be exactly what your child needs.

At The Learnability, we work with children every day who face these exact challenges. In this guide, we will explain what the Seeing Stars program is, how it works, who it is designed for, and what parents can expect when their child begins the program.

By the end of this guide, you will have a clear understanding of whether Seeing Stars could be the missing piece in your child's reading journey.

What Is the Seeing Stars Program?

The Seeing Stars program — officially called Seeing Stars: Symbol Imagery for Phonological and Orthographic Processing in Reading and Spelling — is a structured literacy intervention developed by Nanci Bell at the Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes centre.

The program is designed to develop a specific cognitive skill called symbol imagery — the ability to visualise letters and words as mental pictures. This skill is fundamental to reading and spelling, yet many children with reading difficulties have a significant weakness in this area without anyone realising it.

When a child cannot form clear mental images of letters and words, they struggle to recognise words automatically, decode unfamiliar words accurately, or retain spelling patterns. The Seeing Stars program directly targets and builds this skill through a carefully structured sequence of activities.

To learn more about the full range of Lindamood-Bell based programs we offer, visit our services page.

What Is Symbol Imagery and Why Does It Matter?

Symbol imagery is the ability to create a mental picture of letters and words — to literally see them in your mind. Most fluent readers do this automatically without thinking about it. When you read the word "cat," your brain instantly recognises the pattern of letters as a whole unit. You do not have to sound out each letter every time.

For children who struggle with symbol imagery, reading feels like starting from scratch every single time. They may sound out a word correctly on one line and then fail to recognise the same word three lines later. They may read slowly and laboriously even after months of practice. Spelling often remains weak even when a child seems to understand phonics rules.

This is not a sign that a child is not trying or not intelligent. It is a sign that a specific cognitive skill — symbol imagery — needs to be directly taught and developed. This is precisely what the Seeing Stars program does.

Signs Your Child May Have Weak Symbol Imagery

  • Reads the same word differently each time it appears on a page
  • Struggles to remember sight words even after repeated practice
  • Reads very slowly and has to decode every word individually
  • Spells words incorrectly even when they know the phonics rules
  • Loses their place frequently while reading
  • Finds it hard to read without using their finger to track words
  • Reverses or confuses letters such as b, d, p, and q

If several of these signs are familiar, we recommend speaking with one of our specialists at The Learnability. An assessment can identify exactly where your child's difficulties are coming from and which program is the right fit.

How Does the Seeing Stars Program Work?

The Seeing Stars program works by systematically developing a child's ability to visualise letters and words. It moves through a carefully structured sequence, beginning with individual letters and gradually building toward whole words, sentences, and connected text.

Step 1 — Visualising Single Letters

The program begins at the very foundation — helping students create clear, stable mental images of individual letters. Students practise visualising letters with their eyes open and closed, describing what they see, and checking their mental image against the real letter. This builds the basic skill of symbol imagery from the ground up.

Step 2 — Visualising Letter Sequences

Once students can visualise individual letters clearly, they begin to work with sequences of letters — first two letters, then three, then four and beyond. Students are asked to visualise a sequence, hold it in their mind, and then recall it accurately. This directly builds the working memory for print that fluent reading requires.

Step 3 — Word Reading and Spelling

Students apply their developing symbol imagery skill to real words. They practise reading and spelling words by visualising the whole word as a mental image, rather than sounding out each letter individually. Over time, this builds the automatic word recognition that fluent, effortless reading depends on.

Step 4 — Connected Text

As students' symbol imagery strengthens, they begin applying it to reading connected text — sentences, paragraphs, and full passages. Fluency improves naturally as word recognition becomes more automatic, and reading begins to feel easier and more enjoyable.

Throughout all of these steps, the program uses a multisensory approach — students see, say, hear, and physically engage with letters and words. This is consistent with the principles behind all of our programs at The Learnability, including our Orton-Gillingham tutoring and Wilson Reading System sessions.

Who Is the Seeing Stars Program Designed For?

The Seeing Stars program is suitable for children, teenagers, and adults who have weak symbol imagery affecting their reading and spelling. It is particularly beneficial for:

  • Children with dyslexia who struggle with automatic word recognition
  • Students who have learned phonics but still read slowly or inaccurately
  • Children who reverse or confuse letters and numbers
  • Students with poor sight word retention despite repeated practice
  • Children with reading fluency difficulties
  • Students with weak spelling despite adequate phonics knowledge
  • Children with visual processing difficulties affecting reading

The Seeing Stars program is often used alongside other interventions. For example, a child who also has difficulties with reading comprehension may benefit from combining Seeing Stars with our Visualizing and Verbalizing program, which targets the ability to create mental images of what is read — a different but equally important skill.

Our specialist tutors at The Learnability will always carry out a thorough assessment before recommending a program, to ensure your child receives exactly the right support for their specific needs.

How The Learnability Delivers Seeing Stars Tutoring Online

At The Learnability, we deliver the Seeing Stars program through personalised one-on-one online sessions. Every session is tailored to your child's current level and pace of progress, ensuring they are always working at exactly the right point in the program.

Our tutors are experienced in delivering Seeing Stars in a virtual environment and use a range of interactive digital tools to make the multisensory elements of the program engaging and effective online. Parents consistently tell us that their children respond positively to online sessions — the one-on-one format means every minute of the session is focused entirely on their child.

We also offer a comprehensive Lindamood-Bell Assessment which can identify whether weak symbol imagery is contributing to your child's reading difficulties and confirm whether the Seeing Stars program is the right starting point.

If you are unsure which program is right for your child, you can also explore our full range of reading intervention programs or speak with one of our specialists directly by visiting our contact page.

What Results Can Parents Expect?

Parents who work with The Learnability often notice changes that go beyond reading scores. When symbol imagery strengthens, children begin to recognise words more automatically. Reading feels less effortful. Spelling becomes more consistent. And perhaps most importantly, children begin to approach reading with less anxiety and more confidence.

Progress depends on the individual child, the intensity of sessions, and how consistently the program is followed. However, the Seeing Stars program has a strong track record when delivered by trained, experienced tutors in a structured, consistent way.

Many of the families we work with at The Learnability come to us after years of trying other approaches that did not produce lasting results. What makes the difference is targeting the right underlying skill — and for many children, symbol imagery is exactly that missing piece.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the Seeing Stars program the same as Lindamood-Bell?

The Seeing Stars program was developed by Nanci Bell at Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes, so it is one of the programs within the broader Lindamood-Bell family of programs. Other Lindamood-Bell programs include Visualizing and Verbalizing and the Talkies program, each targeting different underlying skills.

What age is the Seeing Stars program suitable for?

The Seeing Stars program can be used with children from around age 5 or 6 upward, as well as with older students and adults. The program adapts to the student's current level, making it suitable across a wide age range.

How is Seeing Stars different from phonics instruction?

Phonics instruction teaches children to match sounds to letters. The Seeing Stars program develops symbol imagery — the ability to visualise letters and words as mental pictures. Both skills are important for reading. Many children need both, which is why we often combine Seeing Stars with phonics-based approaches such as our Orton-Gillingham tutoring.

Can Seeing Stars be delivered online?

Yes. At The Learnability, we deliver the Seeing Stars program fully online through one-on-one sessions. Our tutors use interactive digital tools to replicate the multisensory experience of in-person sessions effectively in a virtual environment.

How do I know if my child needs the Seeing Stars program?

If your child reads inconsistently, struggles to retain sight words, reverses letters, or reads slowly despite knowing phonics, weak symbol imagery may be contributing to their difficulties. The best way to find out is through a proper assessment. Contact The Learnability today and we will help you understand exactly what your child needs.

Ready to Help Your Child Read With Confidence?

Every child deserves to experience the joy of reading without struggle. If your child has been working hard but not making the progress they deserve, the Seeing Stars program could provide the breakthrough they need.

At The Learnability, our specialist tutors are experienced in delivering the Seeing Stars program online and are ready to support your child every step of the way. We begin with a thorough assessment to make sure we recommend exactly the right program for your child's individual needs.

Book your free trial session today and take the first step toward giving your child the reading confidence they deserve.

You can also contact us directly or call us at (310) 218-9466 — we are always happy to answer your questions and help you find the right path forward for your child.